Monday, December 30, 2019
Is Corporate Social Responsibility a Myth - 620 Words
Although Vazââ¬â¢s (2014, May 14) earlier paper focuses on the modern awareness of Corporate Social Responsibility (CSR), it seems to be biased, clearly avoiding the ill-effects of corporate branding of CSR, as the friendly new face of capitalism. This paper concentrates on the indirect impacts of CSR, such as increased prices on common consumer goods like organic foods, etc. In an attempt to answer a new question, ââ¬Å"Is Corporate Social Responsibility a myth?â⬠this paper also tries to evaluate what Poruthiyil (2013) eloquently states: Throughout their long history, business ethicists have been aware that theorizations intending to address societal goals can be rendered ineffectual when economic goals are prioritized [Arnold (2010); Marens (2010,2007); Worden (2009); Karnani (2007); Wry (2009); Hartman et al. (2003); Freeman (2000); Boatright (1998)]. Is CSR just a marketing tool? Khuranaââ¬â¢s (2012) presentation appears to be very idealistic; he refers to Max Weber, Joseph Schumpeter and Emil Durkheim, the great social theorists, when he states that great leaders create a sense of connection and meaning to people. While idealism is always good, Lorenzo-Moloââ¬â¢s (2009) paper is more realistic, as she provides stark examples to submit that, CSR tends to focus on the significance of proper reporting (or communication) of a corporations do-gooder or rhetoric activities, while overlooking the back stage or hidden activities. Lorenzo-Moloââ¬â¢s (2009) cites Campbell to showShow MoreRelated`` Reign Of Error Is American Education For The Lives Of Our Children? Essay1247 Words à |à 5 Pagesfor reform being promoted by the government and adopted by many states? What should we do to improve our schools and the lives of our children? According to Ravitch, the ââ¬Å"crisisâ⬠concerning American education is actually a myth. In this book, she addresses myth after myth providing adequate clarity and information. She looks deep into the facts and brings to light what is actually happening in education in America in the following areas: test scores, achievement gaps, graduation rates, teachersRead MoreThe Myths : Learning Navigate The Rough Seas Of Ethics1039 Words à |à 5 Pagesââ¬ËUnmasking the Myths: Learning to Navigate the Rough Seas of Ethics, Sophia Kusyk has articulated the myths that corporations perpetuate when engaging in trade and commerce across cultures. There is a blurring of the difference between the necessity of having the correct etiquette in a foreign culture as opposed to pursuing the correct ethics. Cultural relativism and individual subjectivism give rise to the notion that cultural tolerance is of greater import than doing the right thing. The final myth enumeratedRead MoreEssay on Diversity: The Ethical Choice1410 Words à |à 6 Pagesa society that is increasingly made up of minorities (Ki nicki Kreitner, 2008), it is a societal obligation, the ethical choice, and good business, to increase diversity, address equality issues in the workplace, and turn the American melting pot myth into reality. Employers are powerful institutions that are responsible for allocation of resources like salary, benefits, bonuses, and company stocks, based on employee role, span of control, and contribution to the organization. While equal rightsRead MoreOrganizational Contextual Dimension Culture773 Words à |à 4 PagesArtifacts: These are visible components of culture, they are easy to formulate, have some physical shape, yet its perception varies from one individual to another. 1-Rituals and ceremonies: New hire trainings, new hire welcome lunches, annual corporate conferences, awards, offsite meetings and trainings are few examples of most common rituals and ceremonies. 2-Symbols Slogans: These are high level abstraction of the culture; they effectively summarize organizationââ¬â¢s intrinsic behavior. SymbolsRead MoreBatm : Ethical Case Study1412 Words à |à 6 Pages| A grim contradiction: The practice and consequences of corporate social responsibility by British American Tobacco in Malaysia * British American Tobacco Malaysia (BATM) was formed from he merger of Rothmans of Pall Mall (Malaysia) Berhad and Malaysian Tobacco Company Berhad on 3 November 1999. * Today, British American Tobacco Malaysia is the clear market leaderà withà approximately 63% market share, and ranks amongst the top 25 companies on Bursa Malaysia Securities Berhad in terms of marketRead MoreTheories of Corporate Governance1320 Words à |à 6 PagesTheories of Corporate Governance The philosophical foundations of corporate governance Edited by Thomas Clarke Contents Preface Acknowledgements ââ¬ËIntroduction: Theories of Governance ââ¬â Reconceptualizing Corporate Governance Theory After the Enron Experienceââ¬â¢ Thomas Clarke PART 1 ECONOMIC FOUNDATIONS ix xi 1 31 34 45 ââ¬ËThe Managerial Revolution in American Businessââ¬â¢ Alfred D. Chandler Jr ââ¬ËThe Impact of the Corporation on Classical Economic Theoryââ¬â¢ Adolf A. Berle PART 2 AGENCY THEORY Read MoreEthics, Ethics And Human Interaction857 Words à |à 4 PagesIntroduction The question of morals, ethics and human interaction has fascinated our species in our entire history. The fact that most the myths and stories from ancient times and even the behavior of the Greek and Roman gods are all teaching ethical conduct, is an statement of the importance of this field. The word ethics is derived from the Greek word ethos (character), and from the Latin word mores (customs). Collectively, they combine to define how entities choose to interact with one anotherRead MoreInstitutional Shareholder Service vs. Governance Metrics International670 Words à |à 3 PagesIntroduction A good number of companies are going through a lot pressure to allow their corporate governance rated by corporate governance firms like Institutional Shareholder Service (ISS) or Governance Metrics International (GMI). This is to ensure that companies can be able to establish the successfulness and response of a company board is. However, instructional investors have started to use the two governance rating when they want to decide on the kind of company to bring in their stock portfolioRead MoreCadbury and the Environment1582 Words à |à 7 Pagesrequiring improvement. CADBURYââ¬â¢S ACHIEVEMENTS IN FULFILLING NEEDS WITHIN SOCIETY The formal definition os social responsibility is managementsââ¬â¢s obligation to make choices and take actions that will contribute to the welfare and interests of society as well as the organisation (Szwajkowski, 1986; David et al., 1979). As straightforward as this definition seems, social responsibility can be a difficult concept to grasp, because different people have different beliefs about which action improve
Sunday, December 22, 2019
The Economic Reforms Of Argentina Essay - 1809 Words
In December 2015, Argentinaââ¬â¢s newly elected ââ¬Å"Cambiemosâ⬠party (Lets Change) announced it planned on lifting all restrictions on capital flows, allowing practically unlimited access to foreign currency in a process intended to push the pesoââ¬â¢s value to float towards its true market value. The move to liberalize capital flows was a desperate attempt to increase exports and spur economic growth in an economy that has been battling low foreign reserves and double-digit inflation for the past several years. The free-market candidate, Mauricio Macri, was determined to restore investor confidence in Argentina, utterly destroyed by its 2002 record default, a lack of transparency in its economic institutions, and heavy state intervention. With the backing of big business, both domestic and foreign, Macri was able to mobilize a dissatisfied middle-class tired of the leftist protectionism of the past decade. The economic reforms came at a time of extreme political polar ization and civil unrest in Argentina. The Peronist candidate, Daniel Scioli, lost by a very slim margin, leaving the opposition eager to utilize any economic setbacks as political ammunition. For many Argentines, Macriââ¬â¢s neoliberal plans sound awfully reminiscent of the disastrous policies implemented by Carlos Menem in the 1990s. Given the populationââ¬â¢s low tolerance for austerity measures and a ferocious opposition watching every move, Macriââ¬â¢s must walk a tight line if he is to successfully tackle Argentinaââ¬â¢s economicShow MoreRelatedArgentina s Post Crisis Economic Reform925 Words à |à 4 PagesArgentinaââ¬â¢s Post-Crisis Economic Reform I. Summary a. Following a steep currency devaluation and the largest sovereign debt default in history, Argentina entered a deep recession with high unemployment and social upheaval i. Brought to power new govââ¬â¢t ii. With it, a shift away from market-oriented policies toward greater govââ¬â¢t control of the economy in the pursuit of social equity b. Policies reflect priority for financial independence, social equity, and what may be considered a commitment to populistRead MoreThe Allende Governance A New Governance Essay1360 Words à |à 6 Pagesdifferent reforms like privatization and deregulation. With low level of understanding in economics Pinochet hired economists who were tasked with freeing the economy from the previous destruction caused by socialists. According to De Haan by 1970 Chile recorded least freedom in its economy (De Haan et al 220). But later the economy started experiencing major growth from 1980s which increased economic growth from7.2 percent compared to other countries in South America. While the country economic progressRead MoreImf And Negative Impacts On Argentina1082 Words à |à 5 PagesThe IMF and Negative Impacts on Argentina The International Monetary Fund is an organization created in 1945 consisting of 187 member-countries with goals to foster a global cooperative monetary system, promote international trade growth and exchange rate stability, and maintain a multilateral system of payments. The IMF attempts to achieve these goals by surveilling the global economy, providing financial assistance through credits and loans, and by providing technical assistance. The organizationRead MoreThe Argentinian Economic Crisis ( 2001-2002 )992 Words à |à 4 PagesArgentinian Economic Crisis (2001-2002) INTRODUTION In what is considered as one of the worst crisis for a nation, Argentina has suffered significantly over the years and was caught yet again by a financial crisis in 2001. Over the short period of 1998 to 2001, the Argentine economy has lost almost 20 percent of its GDP (Figure 1) while the poverty has risen to an astonishing 42.3% percent (2001) from an already high figure of 18.2% in 1998 (Weisbrot and Sandoval). Figure 1: Argentina GDP source:Read MoreJuan Domingo Peron and the Autonomy Represented by May Day1152 Words à |à 5 Pagesdenied the people of many Latin American regions, like Argentina. Although Argentina had been granted independence from European powers in the 19th century, it seems as if that independence was not fully realized until the leadership of Juan Domingo Perà ³n who brought the power back to the people of Argentina. His leadership advocated a spirit of independence and a sense of autonomy that redefined the way people thought of themselves in Argentina, and correlated a new stronger spirit in the May DayRead MoreChallenges Facing Argentina Offers Its Residents Free Tuition At Its Public Institutions766 Words à |à 4 PagesSummary of Opportunities and Challenges Argentina offers its residents free tuition at its public institutions. While this incentive may seem wonderful for the citizens of Argentina, it has also created multiple issues. Economic hardship has exacerbated these issues. The tuition-free and open-admission policies, while offering students a chance at success, have left the higher education institutions broken as faculty were not being paid appropriately, this has since changed, but littleRead MoreGlobalization in Argentina Essay1323 Words à |à 6 PagesGlobalization in Argentina has affected the country in numerous ways. There are many positives and negatives. Until 1999 globalization seemed to be the reason the country was so prosperous. Pope John Paul II stated, ââ¬Å"From the ethical point of view, can be positive or negative. In fact, there is an economic globalization which brings some positive consequences, as the phenomenon of efficiency and increased production and, with the development of relations bet ween countries in economic, can strengthenRead MoreThe Limits to Macroeconomic Policy Essay1255 Words à |à 6 Pagesadvancements have made it easier than ever for monies to traverse national borders quickly and efficiently. This capability facilitates inflows and outflows of capital in response to signals. Not all of these signals are economic yet the effects can have a devastating impact. Assessment Economic crisis has precipitated many changes throughout the course of history. Whether it is the great depression of the 1930ââ¬â¢s, the Latin Debt crisis in the early 1980ââ¬â¢s or more recently the financial collapse of the URead MoreArgentina s Foreign Policy : Argentina1059 Words à |à 5 Pagesand terrains, Argentina is by no means a small country. Argentina makes up the whole southern half of South America, covering 2.8 million square kilometers (Geographia). Argentina contains some of the world s tallest mountain ranges, vast deserts, and large scale waterfalls (Geographia). Being the eighth largest country in the world with a large amount of natural resources, Argentina has the potential to join the leaders on the global stage. Although having latent potential, Argentina lacks the abilityRead MoreArgentina Briefing1055 Words à |à 5 PagesBriefing: Republic of Argentina The Republic of Argentina is a federal republic. The president is the head of state and commander in chief of the armed forces. The president is elected to a four year term by a national election. The president may only be elected for a second consecutive term. The president may elect his own cabinet and chief of cabinet by himself. However, the chief of cabinet may be removed by majority vote in each of the governments chambers. The country has a bicameral congress
Friday, December 13, 2019
Childcare Policy Proposal Free Essays
The social welfare concern I chose for analysis is the growing concern for affordable daycare in the United States. Two specific problems I will be analyzing are ââ¬Å"latch-key kidsâ⬠and child neglect which are a direct result of not having access to affordable daycare. One of the main factors that contribute to these issues is poverty. We will write a custom essay sample on Childcare Policy Proposal or any similar topic only for you Order Now Poverty has plagued children throughout United States history. Poverty rates are higher among the youngest children ages birth to four years. These children are more vulnerable to long term effects of poverty. According to the National Center for Children in Poverty, ââ¬Å"An estimated forty-two percent of children under the age of eighteen are living below the poverty line. â⬠(NCSC, 2009). About half of the forty-two percent live close to two hundred percent below the line. As the poverty rate rises, more single and low- income parents are in need of affordable daycare. A recent study showed that ââ¬Å"Forty percent of low-income or single-income families spend almost half of their total income on childcareâ⬠(Associated Press, 2007). Although subsidized programs are available, the waiting process can be long and tedious. For example, programs like Operation 3 Breakthrough which provide daycare at no cost to families have close to a thousand families on their waiting list. Because cities are not providing for the growing need childcare, parents are ââ¬Å"forcedâ⬠to seek alternative methods. One alternative parents chose is to leave their children either at home alone or with other siblings. An estimated seventy-seven percent of American kids are considered ââ¬Å"latch-keyââ¬â¢ kidsâ⬠(Another study showed that ââ¬Å"nationwide, parents report leaving more than three million children under thirteen, some as young as five, to care for homeless for at least a few hours a week on a regular basisâ⬠(Associated Press, 2007). SAFETIES is a non-profit organization that is dedicated to reduce and stop preventable child injury and death. SAFETIES recommends that no child under the age of twelve be left alone for any period of time. There is no federal statute on the age a child can be safely left alone; it is left up to the states to decide. In Kansas, the current age a child can be left alone is twelve; however, in Missouri there is no age requirement. Although a child may be aware of emergency and accident prevention, any times they do not have the cognitive capability and Judgment to handle the situation when it occurs. Children four and under require interaction and supervision that another child can not adequately provide to them. ââ¬Å"Children four and under are at a higher risk and make up half of the unintentional injury-related deaths among children fourteen and underâ⬠(Safe Kids, 2010). The bottom line is that the latch-key method of childcare results in an increasing amount of preventable child injury and death. NEGLECT 4 Neglect is federally defined as ââ¬Å"Failure of a parent or guardian to provide needed DOD, clothing, shelter, medical care, or supervision such that the childââ¬â¢s health, safety, and well-being are threatened with harmâ⬠(HAS, 2009). ââ¬Å"An estimated 5. 8 million children are neglected or abused each yearâ⬠(HAS, 2009). Parents that do not have older children rely on neighbors, family members or friends to watch their children. This is sometimes referred to as ââ¬Å"patchworkâ⬠childcare. Out of desperation, other parents leave their children alone at home, public parks, or public libraries. ââ¬Å"Children and their families may be in need of services even though the parent may not be intentionally gleeful. When poverty limits a parentââ¬â¢s resources to adequately provide necessities for the child, services may be offered to help families provide for their childrenâ⬠(American Humane society, 2010). Attachment Theory, (Bowl, 1969) shows certain aspects that all children require and need in order to flourish and grow healthy. In order to have ââ¬Å"Secure attachmentâ⬠children need human physical contact. ââ¬Å"Physical connection means plenty of touch and eye contact. Such things as cradling an infant while feeding, cuddling with a toddler before bedtime, and hugging a teenager increase the sense of physical injection, especially if touch and eye contact take place on a daily basis throughout childhood yearsâ⬠(Wassermann, 2006). Many times the child goes from place to place, to different locations and sometimes watched by ââ¬Å"strangersâ⬠. The child has no stability, permanency or sense of ââ¬Å"home. Permanency is a key factor for early child development. A ââ¬Å"safe havenâ⬠is needed so that when a child feels threatened or afraid, he or she can return to the caregiver for comfort and soothing. If the child is alone or does not receive POLICY PROPOSAL 5 this comfort, they will eventually stop relying on the caregiver and become outdrawn. Children also need a ââ¬Å"secure ba seâ⬠that is provided by the caregiver. This gives them safe and dependable place to explore the world. In many cases the caregiver is not intentionally putting the child in danger, but is simply unaware of the many household dangers to children. Separation distressâ⬠is also detrimental too childââ¬â¢s well-being. When separated from the primary caregiver, the child will immediately become upset and depressed. Many children experience this even in the most ââ¬Å"normalâ⬠, ideal family circumstances. A deficiency in any of these areas can affect a child later down the road. LEGISLATION In the past, the United States has tried to correct this problem through legislation. The Aid to Families with Dependent Children (FADE) was first passed in 1935, provided money for ââ¬Å"reliefâ⬠to help families provide for their children. In 1972, President Nixon built on the idea but changing it to Aid to Dependent Children (DC) trying to switch focus on to the children as opposed to the family. Republicans typically have a ââ¬Å"laissez fairerâ⬠attitude, however all sides felt this was an important issue. Later Temporary Assistance for Needy Families (TANK) was created in 1996 and reformed the DC. With TANK, time limits were put in place, and subsidies were provided to parents to help them care for their children. Currently the federal government allows up to thirty percent of each stateââ¬â¢s TANK funds to be used alongside current child care grants. In the sassââ¬â¢s The Adoption Assistance and Child Welfare act focused on keeping the child with the biological parents at any cost. Later this was reformed into the Adoption and Safe Families Act of 1997. The new act switched the focus from family preservation to safety and permanency of the child. 6 The Child Care and Development Block Grant (JDBC) is a block grant given to tastes to subsidize child care for low-income families if parents are currently employed or enrolled in school. ââ¬Å"Approximately 1. 8 million US children receive funds, 36,300 in Missouri aloneâ⬠(IDS, 2009). The grant only applies to children thirteen and under offering in-kind assistance to their families. ââ¬Å"An average of sixty-six dollars per week given in vouchers to subsidize child careâ⬠(Almanac of Economic Policy, 1995). Another step in the right direction is provided by the Early Childhood Development, Education, and Care Fund (SEDUCE). This is another block grant that is provided to tastes and has many programs set in place to allow the child to remain in the home instead of utilizing facilitated child care. They offer a program called Stay At Home Parent (ASAP) which allows families with children three and younger to receive in- cash and in-kind benefits in order to provide childcare themselves. Other qualifications this program include teen moms, high risk, no permanent residence, unemployed, The family must also be 185% below the poverty line to be eligible. While these programs have been successful with goals regarding abuse, safety, and permanency; the poverty level continues to be at an all time high. LOOKING ABROAD ââ¬â THE NETHERLANDS I chose to compare our policies with The Netherlands. I found that the Netherlands is more progressive with its view of social welfare than the United States, however is far behind almost all other European countries. In The Netherlands they offer what are considered ââ¬Å"General Provisions. â⬠Basically every citizen is entitled to certain basic needs and provisions. General provisions include Child development groups, pre- school playgroups, child day-care, out of school child care, special education, primary 7 education, and youth health services. All of these programs are universal and available to all citizens. The majority of the provisions are geared towards children staying with parents if possible to have a strong family unit. They offer extended maternity and parental leave for both parents to lower the cost and need for facilitated child care centers. The funding fro child care and maternity/parental leave is provided by both national and local municipal authorities. All citizens pay in for the ââ¬Å"greater goodâ⬠of country. LOOKING AHEAD ââ¬â REFORM I propose not to create a new policy but reform the currant policy. I feel that the Child Care and Development Block Grant (JDBC) is meeting the expectations and Laos the program was designed for. Because the problem is growing rapidly, changes need to be made so that we donââ¬â¢t lose control of the situation. The programââ¬â¢s goals would continue to focus on importance of family, and strive to provide stability, permanency, and enrichment to families. I also feel that we need more focus on early child development (birth to four years) because it will play a dramatic role later in these childrenââ¬â¢s lives. Working and collaborating with programs such as Head Start provide care givers tools to provide young children with what they need to thrive. Graduated assignment should be another key factor in the success of the program. Graduated disengagement is one of the most important core functions of social work. As social workers we need to help people build their own support system so that when they complete the process, they donââ¬â¢t feel alone or back where they started. Finding activities and helping them build new trusting relationships is a key factor in this step. They need a support system in place so that when crisis or hardship happens, they POLICY PROPOSAL do not feel hopeless. SERVICES 8 The program I am proposing would be separated into two main groups. The first group is children ages birth to four years and the second would reach children ages five to eighteen years old. Playgroups which are used in the Netherlands as well as many other European countries give young children ages birth to four years old a chance to interact and socialize with other children their age. Licensed facilitators specializing in early education and development will guide volunteers in providing educational and stimulating activities. Meetings would be held three times a week at local schools, churches, parks, and community centers. Keeping the locations in the neighborhoods of he people they are serving will make attending the programs easier for these families. Child day care will also be provided to families that qualify. Accredited programs are required for all programs receiving grant funding implementing the core value competency. The number of locations should be based on the need for each individual community. For example, in areas of greater need, there should also be greater access to programs. I would also like to propose ââ¬Å"Emergencyââ¬â¢ child care. This program would be a temporary ââ¬Å"safeâ⬠arrangement to offer parents ââ¬Å"peace of mindâ⬠if their usual arrangements fall through. For example if the baby-sitter doesnââ¬â¢t show up, or you have a family emergency, you could drop your child off for a short period of time. Children must already be enrolled in the program or be on some corresponding program such TANK to qualify. Companies that provide on-site day care centers for employees will also receive funding as well as tax incentives. This will give the parents incentive to want to keep their Job as well as peace of mind knowing their children are close by. 9 I also feel that more funds should be used for the Stay At Home Parent program to allow children ages four and under to be with their parents. Families that qualify will receive subsidies while working or attending school part-time and stay home with their child rest of the time. For older children ages five to eighteen the program would continue to offer rewarding after school and summer activities. The objective is to get these kids away from the TV and teach them about the world around them. These activities should based on the strengths perspective model. It is important to find something that the child is interested in or desires, so that they can feel like they have a skill or purpose. After school programs would include tutoring, mentoring, counseling, skill building social interaction, violence prevention, and other similar programs. As social workers we must first build a trusting, positive relationship with the people we are working with. Finding common interests help to bridge partnerships and giving them someone they feel they can ââ¬Å"turn to. â⬠It is important to focus on forming positive relationships instead of trying ââ¬Å"treatâ⬠them. These programs will give the children the skills they need to be responsible for their own behavior and become productive members of their communities. I would also like to provide subsidies for summer camps. I found some programs such as the YMCA that offer subsidized summer programs for under-privileged youth already. Many families struggle the most during the summer months when their children are out of school. This would eliminate having to pay for child care the entire three months of summer, as well as give the child something enjoyable to do. 10 Parents would be provided education and resources on child development and health. The program would offer employment resources, resume help, transportation assistance, interview techniques, internet access, and listings for local Job openings in the How to cite Childcare Policy Proposal, Papers
Thursday, December 5, 2019
Violence In The Arts Essay Example For Students
Violence In The Arts Essay Nowadays, it is hard to turn on a television program, catch a movie or buy your younger sibling a video game without encountering a warning for extreme violence. Everyday, our lives are exposed to violence on the screen, whether it is in the latest Sopranos episode or even watching the six oclock news. For quite a while now, people have been demanding that stricter censorship be placed on the media, especially those programs and video games that can easily be obtained by the youth, due to their feelings that this violence can influence people to act out. However, this is not a new idea. Back in ancient Greece, the philosopher Plato believed that exposure to the emotions of the arts (especially drama) would encourage people to act out violent emotions portrayed in the drama. As documented in his work The Republic, Plato believed strongly that the perfect life was comprised of total balance and harmony in ones mindset and that any stimulated emotions would result in an imbalance. The first theorist to challenge Platos idea was his well-known student, Aristotle. We will write a custom essay on Violence In The Arts specifically for you for only $16.38 $13.9/page Order now Aristotle felt that exposure to the strong emotions of the arts had a positive psychological effect on people because it gave them a chance to let out any emotional frustrations that they might have bottled up inside. I concur with the ideas of Plato, being that the media has become such an influential authority in our society, and the constant exposure to violent behavior within the media is creating numbness to it, especially within our children, who are less able to distinguish between factual and fictional. Our society, beginning with a childs parents, should become stricter with Limiting exposure to violent visual entertainment, and only allow a moderate, if any, amount of violence to be seen by impressionable children and young adults. Drama had only recently developed in Ancient Greece when Plato began speaking against it, however it was already a popular part of Greek tradition. The somewhat violent plots that were also deeply entrenched in religious and family tradition, showed morbid situations; such as Oedipus Rex in which a son kills his father and marries his mother. Plato perceived the dramas as dangerous, because he felt that they created confusion, miscommunication and ignorance. He also felt that the entire worlds evils came from a defective sense of reality and that these dramas promoted that. For example, take a young child who grew up somewhat isolated from the outside world and whose only outlet to our society is through the media. His steady contact with violent programs (which in the end, show a happy conclusion no matter what happens throughout) may convince him that this type of behavior is normal and accepted. Plato was concerned especially about the influence that drama and even pornography would have on children, because he felt that their minds were not developed to the full extent in order to differentiate between the right and wrong that they see in the dramas. Many people will be quick to agree that a child should not watch a rated R action movie, yet they still allow them to view a Saturday morning cartoon in which the main character gets run over every episode and still comes back the next week. This can create a faulty understanding of reality to a child, as well as an unsuspecting adult, because it does not clarify that death is final. What about the movies that emulate and perhaps glorify the lives of drug dealers and gangs? Are they encouraging one to participate in this type of lifestyle by making it seem cool and their answer to their life situation or are they simply depicting reality of what goes on in todays inner cities? These questions are similar to an old saying: which came first, the chicken or the egg? .uca9a4ef31943b6e16170bc4a904d9197 , .uca9a4ef31943b6e16170bc4a904d9197 .postImageUrl , .uca9a4ef31943b6e16170bc4a904d9197 .centered-text-area { min-height: 80px; position: relative; } .uca9a4ef31943b6e16170bc4a904d9197 , .uca9a4ef31943b6e16170bc4a904d9197:hover , .uca9a4ef31943b6e16170bc4a904d9197:visited , .uca9a4ef31943b6e16170bc4a904d9197:active { border:0!important; } .uca9a4ef31943b6e16170bc4a904d9197 .clearfix:after { content: ""; display: table; clear: both; } .uca9a4ef31943b6e16170bc4a904d9197 { display: block; transition: background-color 250ms; webkit-transition: background-color 250ms; width: 100%; opacity: 1; transition: opacity 250ms; webkit-transition: opacity 250ms; background-color: #95A5A6; } .uca9a4ef31943b6e16170bc4a904d9197:active , .uca9a4ef31943b6e16170bc4a904d9197:hover { opacity: 1; transition: opacity 250ms; webkit-transition: opacity 250ms; background-color: #2C3E50; } .uca9a4ef31943b6e16170bc4a904d9197 .centered-text-area { width: 100%; position: relative ; } .uca9a4ef31943b6e16170bc4a904d9197 .ctaText { border-bottom: 0 solid #fff; color: #2980B9; font-size: 16px; font-weight: bold; margin: 0; padding: 0; text-decoration: underline; } .uca9a4ef31943b6e16170bc4a904d9197 .postTitle { color: #FFFFFF; font-size: 16px; font-weight: 600; margin: 0; padding: 0; width: 100%; } .uca9a4ef31943b6e16170bc4a904d9197 .ctaButton { background-color: #7F8C8D!important; color: #2980B9; border: none; border-radius: 3px; box-shadow: none; font-size: 14px; font-weight: bold; line-height: 26px; moz-border-radius: 3px; text-align: center; text-decoration: none; text-shadow: none; width: 80px; min-height: 80px; background: url(https://artscolumbia.org/wp-content/plugins/intelly-related-posts/assets/images/simple-arrow.png)no-repeat; position: absolute; right: 0; top: 0; } .uca9a4ef31943b6e16170bc4a904d9197:hover .ctaButton { background-color: #34495E!important; } .uca9a4ef31943b6e16170bc4a904d9197 .centered-text { display: table; height: 80px; padding-left : 18px; top: 0; } .uca9a4ef31943b6e16170bc4a904d9197 .uca9a4ef31943b6e16170bc4a904d9197-content { display: table-cell; margin: 0; padding: 0; padding-right: 108px; position: relative; vertical-align: middle; width: 100%; } .uca9a4ef31943b6e16170bc4a904d9197:after { content: ""; display: block; clear: both; } READ: Preserving Our Earth EssayThe skewed perspective portrayed by movies, television, and video games can create a lack of sensitivity to emotional and/or physical harm. It may even cause them to want to emulate the kind of lifestyle they are seeing, thinking that it is a reflection of real life. Aristotle, on the other hand, believed that the best dramas were those which an ordinary person greatly misjudges, because this allowed the ordinary people who viewed it to realize the error and make it a moral learning experience a moral laboratory in which we can see our inner urges acted out and learn from the tragic consequences. (Rosenstand, pg. 52) I agree somewhat with Platos views on censorship, since you never know exactly how someone will react to viewing a violent situation and whether they will be able to use their common sense and judgment to refrain from copying the actions of the characters. There have been many examples of copycats who have gotten their ideas from watching a violent film, but many will still argue that the majority is simply coincidence. In the end of the thriller Scream, Billy makes an important comment to Sidney, telling her not to blame the movies! Movies dont create psychos! Movies make psychos more creative! . However, a point that must be understood is that even though Aristotle was for the viewing of emotionally charged dramas, he also advocated a moderation of these violent stories. We should remember that the drama that Aristotle recommended as beneficial was not available twenty-four hours a day, as it is on a TV set; Greek dramas were originally performed once a year? . (Rosenstand, pg. ) If Aristotle were around today, he probably would advise about the effects of being overly exposed to the elements of moral decay in the visual entertainment and suggest a need for censorship as well. Viewing a documentary on the Civil War in a students classroom is one thing, since those are factual events that took place in our societys history, but allowing a child to play the video game Mortal Combat on a daily basis is unnecessary and does not provide an educational experience or an emotional outlet when constantly employed as a means of entertainment. Plato felt that censorship was necessary, especially for childrens materials, because he didnt trust people to distinguish between right and wrong on their own. In order to avoid a complete and rigid censorship put on by our societys government, parents should on their own monitor what their children are exposed to. I believe that the parent should decide what amount of violence, if any, they want their child to be exposed to and regulate that amount strictly until that child has reached an age in which he or she can determine between fantasy/reality, good/bad. Parents should also explain that the reality that is depicted in films, television programs and video games are not necessarily how real life is conducted. Parents with young children may want to compare it to a fairy tale, such as Hansel and Gretel, to illustrate a moralistic point. I feel that in order to reduce the chances of violent behavior later on in a persons life, they need to be taught, as a child that the way they see disagreements and issues being handled in violent entertainment is not the appropriate manner of solving them. This way the child will grow to understand and refrain from acting out the emotions represented in their favorite action movie or video game. In summary, I feel that after reflecting on Plato and Aristotles views on the problem of over stimulation of the emotions by drama, I found that I have been influenced by both of their opinions. Both philosophers made valid points, which should be recognized by todays society.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)